The article was measuring how teams performed in 2017 compared to the preseason prediction for each of them. Based upon this metric, Rutgers received a respectable C+. Not bad, but certainly not great. It means that we did a little better than expected, but just barely. But, how did our Big Ten brethren do? That is, did they exceed, meet, or disappoint their pre-season expectations?
Let’s take a look by grade and see how they fell:
A+ (Teacher’s Pet)- Wisconsin
Wisconsin certainly did exceed almost everyone’s expectation for 2017. While expected to be able to compete in the weaker Big Ten West, they absolutely did better than that, and finished with a division title, as well as a convincing win in the Orange Bowl over #10 Miami. They finished the season with an enviable 13-1 record.
A (Really Good Students): #5 Ohio State, #9 Penn State, #16 Michigan State
So, these schools all did very well in 2017. Michigan State recovered from a 3-9 record in 2016, and wound up with a 10-3 record in 2017, as well as a Holiday Bowl victory over #18 Washington State. Ohio State narrowly missed being in the playoff this year, and finished with a convincing win over #9 USC. Penn State ended their season 11-2, losing only to the other two teams that got an A, OSU, and MSU.
A- (Good Students): Purdue, Northwestern
Purdue made it back to a bowl game this season for the first time in five seasons, finishing with a 7-6 record for first year head coach Jeff Brohm. While they did stumble a bit through the season, a win over Missouri at the beginning of the season, and finishing with wins against Iowa and a bowl win over Arizona.
Northwestern went 10-3 overall, finished in second place in the West division with a 7-2 record,and beat Kentucky 24-23 in the Music City Bowl. They ended the season on an impressive 8 game winning streak.
B (Well Respected Students): Iowa
While their record isn’t a lot different from 2016, the Hawkeyes claim to fame in 2017 is the amazing job they did dismantling Ohio State back in November. That not only shocked everyone, but was the event that doomed the Buckeye’s chances to get into the Playoff this year.
B- (Solid Students): Michigan
Harbaugh’s Heroes had a good season, but was marred by losing the two games that matter most to any Wolverine, Ohio State and Michigan State. Add to that being the only Big Ten team that lost their bowl game this season, and you can see why grumbles are beginning to be heard in Ann Arbor. After all, much is expected from those winged helmets each year!
C+ (Really Tried): Rutgers
While a 4-8 record doesn’t sound like a great season, the Scarlet Knights did double their wins from 2016. With three conference victories this season (the most since 2014, and three more than in 2016), things may be looking up in Piscataway.
C- (Meh): Indiana, Maryland, Minnesota
All three of these teams failed to turn heads this year. Indiana did not win the games they needed to win, and missed out on an opportunity to go to a bowl three seasons in a row for the first time. Maryland had a terrible time keeping a healthy quarterback on the field, and so went from 3-1 to 3-9. Minnesota also looked good in their 3-0 start, but badly stumbled in the stretch for first year head coach P.J. Fleck.
D (Ugh!): Illinois
Illinois was kept from a failing grade this year only because the expectations were very low. However, they actually fell somewhat below the level of play they were expected to meet. Love Smith’s chair may be warming up in Champaign.
F (Dunce Cap): Nebraska
There’s not much positive to say about the Cornhuskers in 2017. They were not expected to compete for the Big Ten West title, but they were certainly expected to be a competitive member of the conference. As the season progressed, the team regressed, and it cost Mike Riley his head coaching position. Now, all eyes will be on Nebraska to see if former ‘Husker quarterback Scott Frost can bring some of his UCF magic to Lincoln.
Well, there you have it, the grades as compiled by Paul Myerberg. I feel he did a great job in his ranking not only of the Big Ten, but all 130 teams in the FBS. What do you think?
Do you think these grades are deserved for the teams in the Big Ten?
This poll is closed
Oh yeah, he nailed it!
It was pretty close
Eh, not so much
Are you kidding me?
Did Rutgers deserve a C+ for their 2017 season?
This poll is closed
Absolutely, they improved and somewhat exceeded expectations
No, they did not progress enough to deserve that grade
They did much better than a C+!
They belonged with Illinois or Nebraska if you ask me!